The only reason I gave it 4 starts instead of 5 was because the lipstick tube is clear and I was excited to see the gold case in the picture (I personally just feel like the clear twist tube is ugly) but overall I'm IN LOVE with this!! It's a perfect shade for me because I like very natural lip colors. It's slightly glossy which I love because I have very dry lips. At first when you put it on there seems like there's no color but as you keep applying the color starts to show up! I also did a smudge test and wiped my mouth with my fingers and nothing really smudged onto my face (noticeably) because the lipstick is partially clear and glossy. Overall I love it (minus the case). Also the flower looks so pretty!!!